This issue centers on the 'youth crime crisis' narrative currently dominating Australian media. Critics of the current system call it 'catch and release,' arguing that magistrates are too lenient on teenagers who steal cars or break into homes. However, legal experts warn that incarcerating children significantly increases the likelihood of adult offending and that bail reform often targets vulnerable Indigenous youth. Proponents argue that community safety must come first and that consequences for crime must be immediate. Opponents argue that locking up children does not address the root causes of poverty, and simply entrenches them in the criminal justice system.
Response rates from 140 Australia voters.
Trend of support over time for each answer from 140 Australia voters.
Loading data...
Loading chart...
Trend of how important this issue is for 140 Australia voters.
Loading data...
Loading chart...
Unique answers from Australia voters whose views went beyond the provided options.
@9XQ7747 3wks3W
@BBZG4BQ3mos3MO
First we need to repeal Doli Incapax. Then change the law so magistrates can convict without a guilty plea, and divert to behaviour change and remediation programs to prevent kids being jailed and 'institutionalised' which just hardens the criminality. Must rely on psych evaluation and community and victim input.
If there's a chance we can divert them from a life of crime, then we should do everything to ensure that happens.
Apart from anything else it's cheaper than maintaining jails and cleaning up afterwards, like insurances for thefts, burglaries, hospital costs, murders etc etc..
Jail should be for those who won't repent, have no remorse, or are otherwise unable to recover or reflect or rehabilitate.
Join in on the most popular conversations.
Based on 140 responses to this question.
These results come from iSideWith's ongoing political issues survey. We collect over a million responses per day, filter out duplicate and multiple submissions, and break the results down by political party, ideology, age, state, and census demographics (income, race, education, household).
iSideWith is non-partisan — we don't advocate for any party, candidate, or position. We report what the public tells us.
Writing about this issue? Use the live data and link back to the full results.
