Try the political quiz
+

Filter by author

Narrow down the conversation to these participants:

60 Replies

 @ISIDEWITHDiscuss this answer...2yrs2Y

Yes

 @9P4BD2Ldisagreed…2yrs2Y

No

Hamas are the government of Gaza. When they attacked Israel on October 7, they did so representing the Gazan people. The response to this attack in Gaza was that of euphoria - dancing in the street and celebrations.

Continually, Gazan authorities have placed their civilians in the line of fire against international law and blamed Israel when they ended up hurt or killed. When Gaza infrastructure is attacked, the number of casualties claimed always far exceeds the actual number - the Gazan ministry of Health claimed 500+ casualties at Al-Shifa hospital caused by an Israeli bomb - it turned out…  Read more

 @9ZSZJSXIndependentdisagreed…2yrs2Y

Hamas is still holding Israeli hostages and has agreed to no ceasefire which includes returning them. There should be no ceasefire until all hostages are returned.

 @B9LW33GOne Nationdisagreed…5mos5MO

Israel needs to completely destroy hamas, islamic jihad, Houthis and Hezbollah...they have the right to be safe and not have the constant terrorist attacks against them they have experienced for nearly 100 plus years.

 Deletedcommented…1wk1W

 @B9DN3GLfrom New Jersey  disagreed…5mos5MO

Israel was attacked and has the right to defend itself. Plus, Hamas kept the hostages. The war could have ended anytime Hamas wanted to release the hostages and stop firing rockets.

 @ISIDEWITHDiscuss this answer...2yrs2Y

No

 @B9LW33GOne Nationagreed…5mos5MO

Just need to look at the intifadas and genocides committed against Israel by the islamic terrorist groups.

 @B8Z6YBVOne Nation agreed…6mos6MO

My position is morally defensible, I do not have to defend this negative. The conflict in Gaza is one millennia in the making and we have no business involving ourselves. If innocent people are har.ed letting their ideologies burn themselves out, so be it.

 @B24STGSLaboranswered…1yr1Y

Yes, but Hamas is to lay down its arms and dissolve, the hostages are to be released, and the Israelis must be subjected to a more 'boots on the ground' review.

 @B2L49CSanswered…1yr1Y

The government should call for an end to Hamas rule in Gaza as a pre-condition for a permanent ceasefire.

 @B2CYF93answered…1yr1Y

No, tell Hamas to surrender. If Hamas surrenders the war is over straight away.

 @B2CRG6DOne Nationanswered…1yr1Y

No, Hamas has support of Palestinian people and will just regroup and continue attacking Israel. They want nothing less but destruction of Israel and Jews. Israel is in an existential fight for survival

 @9ZSZJSXIndependentanswered…2yrs2Y

No, not until all hostages are released and Gaza is no longer under Hamas terrorist rule

 @BBXGKX2answered…3mos3MO

No, this is none of our business and being involved offers no benefit to the Australian people, nor do we have any tangible influence on it in the first place

 @BBCG5C5One Nationanswered…4mos4MO

Absolutely not, due to terrorist organisations like Hamas, we should be sending aid to Israel, to help diminish Hamas

 @B9SQSHWOne Nationanswered…4mos4MO

I believe that Australia should instead, take Gaza as its own, and use it to begin Christo-Pagan crusades into Israel and the West Bank.

 @B9NBQWCanswered…5mos5MO

Demand a plan for peace and justice in Israel and Palestine, to end the genocide in Gaza, to free all remaining Israeli hostages, demand Hamas to disarm, Netanyahu to be sent to ICC with Hamas leaders and for elections in their respective societies. Push for an end to Israeli settler occupation in West Bank and protect Jerusalem and important Holy places by putting them in a neutral territory managed by Christian, Jewish and Muslim leaders. Push for two-state solution.

 @B8LQM38answered…7mos7MO

I call for the Government to ensure all Israeli hostages are released, Palestinian genocide is ended, Israel to stop occupation in parts of West Bank, launch Jerusalem as a third UN-Vatican-Israel-Palestine state and call Hamas to disarm

 @B7CLSGSanswered…9mos9MO

No, the Australian government should call for the release of the hostages, and the destruction of Hamas.

 @B6G3KTWanswered…10mos10MO

Yes, provided the hostages are released and both sides promise to refrain from actions that harm civilians on both sides, and the Israelis allow for food and aid to be sent into the strip.

 @B5KSPJWanswered…1yr1Y

Id want a ceasefire in both sides. I don't really stand for either side hurting each other and we should also stay out of this mess before it gets us into it.

 @B57NYYHanswered…1yr1Y

Yes; enough destruction and blood shed has occurred in Gaza, and a permanent ceasefire would bring the beginning of peace.

 @B3RQLDRfrom 20  answered…1yr1Y

 @B3QHXY3answered…1yr1Y

The stats given in the description above are biased and show heavy favour to one side of the story.

I support international pressure for a ceasefire, but the conditions included must be that Israel returns the Palestinian territory it has seized since the beginning of the war. Hamas must also be removed from Government and both countries face an international court for war crimes. Palestine should be internationally recognised as a country.

Israel needs be pressured to end its conflicts in Lebanon and all other territories it is attempting to occupy. We cannot encourage expansionistic colonising mindset, or it will lead to a repeat of the current situation.

 @B3F3Z95answered…1yr1Y

 @B39JGHXanswered…1yr1Y

 @B4XPQN3answered…1yr1Y

Yes, provided that both sides show commitment to show restraint and a willingness to negotiate in good faith and that the hostages or their remains get released.

 @B4LNTNWanswered…1yr1Y

Stick to home issues and stop importing trouble makers who refuse to sssimikate before Australia is its own war zone

 @B4JJCRGanswered…1yr1Y

I support the government putting boots on the ground to physically stop the Palestinian genocide being conducted by Israel.

 @B4BF5P3 answered…1yr1Y

Yes, and Israeli government officials and IDF officers wanted by the ICC should be treated as war criminals.

 @B44DXFKfrom Washington  answered…1yr1Y

 @B3XZGQQanswered…1yr1Y

In theory absolutely, however it depends if Hamas accepts the existence of Israel. Gaza had decades and huge amounts of fundings from Arab nations to make the place better but spent on weapons and tunnels. Israel has the right to exist and decent itself. The government hasn't been tough enough calling out Hamas and Palestinians supporters in Australia.

 @B3TZ7VFanswered…1yr1Y

Yes, but I would also want to see the hostages taken by Hamas to be released unconditionally.

 @B39866FLaboranswered…1yr1Y

 @B2ZHWGDanswered…1yr1Y

 @9ZM933Ganswered…2yrs2Y

Austrslia needs to back out of areas where its not our business. Get these people out of our country and get us out of theirs!

 @9YLJ57BGreensanswered…2yrs2Y

Yes, but only if it means returning the land to Palestine under International Law

 @9QYFR26answered…2yrs2Y

No, not until HAMAS is defeated because otherwise it is just kicking the can down the road to come back later

 @9QQ3G63answered…2yrs2Y

I don't believe Australia needs to take a stance on matters concerning the Middle East.

 @9PDPBQYanswered…2yrs2Y

Yes, but instead of a military approach, we should help Israel take a diplomatic approach in conquering Hamas.

 @9NVZ3QLCoalitionanswered…2yrs2Y

Yes, but instead of a military approach, we should help take a diplomatic approach towards ending Hamas' rule in Gaza.

 @9JTJ6RFAustralian Democratsanswered…2yrs2Y

No, Hamas has demonstrated, it will not abide by a ceasefire and will continue to use Hostages and Palestinians as human shields

 @9W2J5CJanswered…2yrs2Y

Gaza has been allowed to operate as a terrorist nation for too long, and needs to have a stop put to it.

 @9S5RWFVanswered…2yrs2Y

No, I don’t support the genocide of Israel. A proper solution is in order, not telling the victim the rats can hurt them as they please.

 @9N9NYLWanswered…2yrs2Y

No, a permanent ceasefire in Gaza would destroy the Israeli state and would displace Jews

 @9M8CT84answered…2yrs2Y

No, but unless you have to remove the terrorists to keep Palestinians alive until the end of the war, Israel will pay for the damage in Gaza that was destroyed and kill innocent people.

 @9K8TZN2New Liberalanswered…2yrs2Y

No. Not without a call for / resolution for the immediate return of hostages and immediate laying down of arms by Hamas, whose direct actors must be imprisoned. Followed by the dissolution of Hamas and UNWRA

 @9QYDNKNanswered…2yrs2Y

No. Gaza have sown the wind, and are now reaping the whirlwind. A ceasefire would undermine the efforts of the IDF and show the West is more concerned about optics than doing what has to be done.

 @9P4BD2Lanswered…2yrs2Y

No

There is no reason for a ceasefire to be entertained at this time.

Gaza have shown that their only desire is for the destruction of Israel and the killing of the Jews living there. Every time that Israel or anyone else has extended an olive branch to them, they either rejected it outright or took it and then attacked them immediately. They see mercy as weakness - and so they will respond with war. If they desire war so greatly, they shall have war - in all of its brutality. Perhaps, when they are treated like the losers in a war, they will see reality.

It took the total and utter annihilation of Germany and Japan's ability to wage war in order to get…  Read more

 @9QX8952Coalition  from GU  answered…2yrs2Y

No

No, the Gazans don't deserve peace. Not until they surrender unconditionally.

 @B2WGS2Xanswered…1yr1Y

Yes, the government should call for a permanent ceasefire in Palestine, Lebanon, and all other territories that Israel is currently attempting to occupy. The government should also call on Israel to cease its occupation of Palestine, and cease their expansionist actions. We should also commit to prosecuting any war criminals that make it onto Australian soil, regardless of their nationality. It is also vitally important that Australia firmly insists that our allies cease dealing arms to any state that is infringing on the sovereignty of another, and that we ensure we also do not engage in this profiteering, war mongering behaviour.

 @9KC3W25Laboranswered…2yrs2Y

I believe that there should be a permanent ceasefire on both sides wherein Hamas stops using both Palestinians and Israeli as shields and where Israel is held responsible for the unjust genocide and continued segregation of Palestinians. No one's hands are clean. This is the escalation of an apartheid within the nation that has been present since its partition, it needs to be resolved in diplomacy, not violence.

 @B526L7NSocialist Allianceanswered…1yr1Y

Yes, Australia as it stands is complicit i the genocide of Palestinians and can and we must do more to see Israel held accountable for its war-crimes

Demographics

Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion

Loading data...