In January 2018 Germany passed the NetzDG law which required platforms like Facebook, Twitter and YouTube to take down perceived illegal content within 24 hours or seven days, depending on the charge, or risk a fine of €50 million ($60 million) fines. In July 2018 representatives from Facebook, Google and Twitter denied to the U.S. House of Representatives Judiciary committee that they censor content for political reasons. During the hearing Republican members of Congress criticized the social media companies for politically motivated practices in removing some content, a charge the…
Read moreNarrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Ideology:
Federal Electorate:
Local Government Area:
State Electorate:
Postcode:
Suburb:
Yes and no, the social media sites should not be spreading fake news and misinformation, however, policies need to be in place to ensure the government is not using that to spread propaganda and keep citizens in the dark about what is actually going on.
@B2HMHT51wk1W
No, but there should be a fact-checking system separate from both the government and the site to prevent government control
@B2FTPK3 2wks2W
Yes, to an extent. Repeat offenders of spreading deliberately incorrect information should be liable to punishment for something in a similar vein to defamation.
Yes, but give the duty to a body independent of the government, and make it an offense for any member of government to try and influence this body.
@B22YG9J2mos2MO
The government needs to worry more about videos and photos of people dying on social media that are traumatic, not fake news…
@9ZR2LN52mos2MO
Yes and they should be organised into a single state corporation to improve efficiency and reduce leftist misinformation
@9W899H93mos3MO
Should not regulate, but some misinformation are too serious which an action from the official should be taken.
@9S7289P6mos6MO
Government shouldn't regulate, but they do need the power to go after & shut down fake news & misinformation.
@9PS5PFL7mos7MO
They should reuglate social media sites, but not as a means to prevent fake news and misinformation. They should be monitored for illegal activity.
@9LXD7C99mos9MO
Provide a service which can debunk and fact-check claims and require social media sites to take down posts pending an investigation.
There should be a regulation on fake news and misinformation, but only if the government is trustworthy, which is rare.
@9G6YC251yr1Y
Both public and private involvement to regulate this is necessary to increase likelihood of fair and reasonable regulation over either sides political alignment
@9QZJSXK7mos7MO
This is a complex question. Farm trolls and deliberate misinformation need to be dealt with. Perhaps it should be a condition of social media platforms operating that they strenuously moderate their sites?
@92TWW7W3yrs3Y
No, though the algorithm that continually feeds the same content (click bait) should be banned, so users are exposed to all information not just one that feeds the same narrative (bias)
@92P87YR3yrs3Y
The government should make it illegal for social media companies to remove news that the company doesn’t agree with only removing illegal activity
@92KRJL83yrs3Y
There should be legislation that holds social media companies accountable if harmful misinformation is spread
@92KNTVX3yrs3Y
No, but they should put in place something to make sure that the social media companies make sure there is no fake news
Social media should be regulated the same as television, radio and advertising. Anything blatantly false or defamatory should be removed and the platform should be fined
@92DKT5R3yrs3Y
Yes, but the government should have an external independent organisation regulate and prevent fake news and misinformation.
@92DKHTJLiberal Democrat3yrs3Y
No, the government should not determine what is fake or real news & No, social media companies are private and should not be regulated by the government.
@92C9PYH3yrs3Y
Web platforms should be required to fact check and declare results for any high reach content.
@92C3XDD3yrs3Y
No, but social media companies should be monitored by social conscience.
Lying should be made illegal at a news & media level
No, the government should not determine what is fake or real news but an independant body should be set up to regulate social media sites and fake news/misinformation.
Yes, but don't regulate right wing media too strictly
An independent authority appointed by parliament should oversee this
Yes, but only if the government is completely honest about the news that is being spread, and not use the regulations to support any propaganda.
Social media should be regulated but not government controlled
I think it would be micro managing for the government to have control over everything we are viewing. Let people decide for themselves by giving them the information.
@8ZFGSBZ3yrs3Y
No, but independent impartial regulation should be mandatory
@8Z6QVGM3yrs3Y
Yes, but through legislation which puts responsibility on the sites
@8YWMRGYIndependent3yrs3Y
Yes, but they should only change the algorithm, not censor information
The government can't determine what is fake or real, as it could be used for their political agenda. But hate speech should be regulated.
Only companies who refuse to implement their own regulations
@8YHWBXV3yrs3Y
no but increase the oversight and penalties for sites
@8Y6DL923yrs3Y
It's impossible to truly do this; any implementable system to censor the internet beyond what measures are already in place would be far too authoritarian and an egregious offence to the rights of citizens.
Yes, but an independent body needs to be responsible for regulating and defining 'fake news'.
@8XVXFF2Independent3yrs3Y
No, introduce a 1st admendmant type law which only limits a private institutions ability to restrict free speech
a third organisation should be regulating social media to prevent fake news and misinformation.
The government spread the misinformation themselves.
@Yods083yrs3Y
Difficult question as the media will scream about freedom of speech. However, this sector can have devastating impact on people’s lives. We definitely don’t want a Trump here in Australia. So possible some regulation is required with the ability for the Government to shut them down if breaches occur.
@8W2CSWBUnited Australia3yrs3Y
The problem with this question is who fact checks the fact checkers? Who funds these companies because that's where the current problem lies within social media fact checking
Yes, but only if they also regulate traditional media outlets
@8TYNNZB3yrs3Y
No, but it should be regulated through independent, non-partisan third parties
Yes, as long as the information is political and deemed false and potentially dangerous
@8TMB9YWLiberal Democrat4yrs4Y
Social media companies should be regulated, it’s not the government’s job to regulate their content.
@8TLHSVKIndependent4yrs4Y
Yes, but only to prevent their terms of service being selectively or arbitrarily enforced
Yes and they should also monitor the news put on the TV and actively abolish political biases like the Murdoch press's bias towards the Liberal Party
@8THSFT74yrs4Y
No, the government should not determine what is fake or real news. Social media companies also should not determine what is fake or real news.
@Anderson94yrs4Y
No, but social media sites and all news outlets should be regulated by an NGO
Social media sites should regulate the posts that are on their sites.
@8R7MJ334yrs4Y
Government action should only be taken if the fake news or misinformation in question is becoming influential across a significant majority. Often, fake news is debunked online quickly by audiences anyway, so mass government intervention is unnecessary.
@8QM3RVW4yrs4Y
these processes need to be in place, but they should be undertaken by an independent organization.
@8PF35LM4yrs4Y
Yes, but the government should make companies liable to self-regulation
@8P275NX4yrs4Y
If they do then the need to do the same to msm too
@8KMBSPB4yrs4Y
No, but an opinion or fact note could be made to reduce misinformation
@8KH58484yrs4Y
No, because the controlling government could use it to push out opposition truths
@8K3DZCZ4yrs4Y
they should confirm what is fake or real news
@8H8BVC64yrs4Y
Companies should be required to police this
@8GZFRC44yrs4Y
Yes, however, the government should hire an independent group to do the regulating so that political interference is not involved.
@8GLJL4L4yrs4Y
Yes, social media needs to be screened for fake news, however this would need to be carried out by an external agency or body that has no political ties, the same way the judicial system is separated from government
@8GL9JSM4yrs4Y
Yes, social media companies are politically biased and need to be regulated, however the same applies for government-backed institutions
@8G6435D4yrs4Y
Yet again, not a black v white question. So not regulation, but yes to legislation
@8F953DT4yrs4Y
Yes, by strengthening prosecution laws.
@8DRXD444yrs4Y
yes and no, there is certainly lots of fake news out there but this could be used as a way for governments to over regulate and control their citizens through social media
@8D2H6GM4yrs4Y
How about the government just let social media companies run their social media. If there is fake news, it will be known by the general public because we talk.
@8CJMFKT4yrs4Y
No, there should be regulation, but not from the government as politicians are not independent, and too much of the misinformation online is politically motivated
@97QYKRP2yrs2Y
Probably not because I feel like that should be the responsibility of the social media companies
@8ZQ8G423yrs3Y
Yes, but as long as we don’t cross the boundary into censorship.
No, however the social media companies should regulate their sites to prevent fake news and misinformation.
@8RC6QNY4yrs4Y
No, but social media sites should have incentives to regulate their platform in an unbiased manner.
@8G3TXHV4yrs4Y
Social media companies should be legally required to regulate their own platforms to prevent fake news and misinformation.
I can't trust the government to regulate social media, there is too high a chance they censor left wing news and views.
Yes, but give social media companies a chance to self regulate first.
@992CZX42yrs2Y
Social media companies shpuld be fined
No, to protect free speech, but teach people about what is fake and real.
@HippopiJ3yrs3Y
Yes but only to the extent of political, health and scientific news.
@HippopiJ3yrs3Y
Only to the extent of political, health and scientific news.
No, this would be a breach of privacy
There needs to be some regulation but not by the government
@934XKY63yrs3Y
No, the government needs to spend more on getting out the factual message
@934TBGJ3yrs3Y
I think it should be regulated but not just over fake news, bullying & hate speech seems to be a more important target. There should also be age restrictions in place as so much of these issues seem to stem from teenager - young adult age groups
More regulation needs to be done on the internet as a whole, we could look at utilising technology to create an AI that is able to verify information, references, sources et certra and provide a score on the validity of the website, article, information et cetra so people could make more informed decisions.
@933LBHL3yrs3Y
No the government should improve education levels and promote positive reporting of news by media outlets
@932ZMLZ3yrs3Y
Hold them legally responsible and they will regulate themselves.
@92ZFQJB3yrs3Y
People shouldnt be gullible nimrods. There is not one unbiased news program in Australia making it impossible to get balanced views like myself
@92YQS8F3yrs3Y
Neither I don’t trust social media or believe all the information the government provides us is correct
This is a difficult question that requires nuance
Not necessarily regulate per say but at least hold the social media sites accountable for any misinformation, especially if they go viral
@92WFQ2M3yrs3Y
No, but an independent unbiased body should stop the spread of Fake news and Misinformation.
@92VMJHQ3yrs3Y
No, but there should be funding put towards fact checking sites and information hubs to help citizens easily identify misinformation
@95GWW3Q2yrs2Y
The government should be able to highlight things as fake or satire but should not be able to hide or delete tweets from the public.
No, but social media companies should be liable for content on their platforms
@ISIDEWITH5mos5MO
@ISIDEWITH5mos5MO
@ISIDEWITH5mos5MO
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.