Australian hospitals are currently allocated funding on a fixed price for each treatment they provide. Proponents see this plan as making hospitals more efficient and providing an equal level of care. Opponents believe it causes hospitals to offer more expensive treatments in order to maximize their profits.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
State:
Federal Electorate:
Local Government Area:
No, this will commercialize hospitals and turn them into a business. They are a public necessity of the people that should be provided at minimal or no cost.
@9WQCZRQ2mos2MO
Yes. I think leave the decision of what treatment is required by the actual treating physician instead. However, regular oversight of the costs should be conducted by trained professionals if concerned about unnecessary expensive treatments being used or have a hospital protocol of when to use certain treatments. Most physicians tend to use cost/time/best treatment for patients to prevent re-hospitalization. No one wants a pt to keep coming back especially in teh public system.
@9W7QKM53mos3MO
This needs to be case by case. People that have lost their jobs due to an injury, chronic illness, born with a disability sometimes require expensive surgeries, procedures and medication. Yet they can't afford it. So we have no choice but to go public, and the waiting lists are horible and can make our conditions worse. It's not about hospitals pushing for more expensive tests. Overall we just want something better.
@9S2XYG55mos5MO
Yes, and introduce legislation to stop hospitals from using unnecessary expensive treatments on patients in order to make a profit
@9M6YVS5Independent8mos8MO
private health should be subsidized for all citizens, can easily be funded for all if we legalize selling marijuana can even build some houses :o
@9JKG8RG11mos11MO
Healthcare should not be free, as the government needs to fund other services and healthcare can be used as a way to develop the economy further.
@8RC6QNY4yrs4Y
Yes, but with moderation to ensure that patients aren't exploited for profit.
@93R3M8Y3yrs3Y
The model use should reflect the most effective and efficient practice and be evidence base best practice
@9353BBF3yrs3Y
Yes; hospitals should be funded on a fee-for-service model, with standardised costs set for said services nationwide, in conjunction with additional general funding.
@933VHD63yrs3Y
Profit should not be the motivation. We can go with out other things in favor of free health not focused on profit.
@92TP7CJ3yrs3Y
yes, but something must be put in place so that this model does not encourage hospitals to use unnecessary expensive treatments on patients in order to make a profit
@92N3D7W3yrs3Y
Yes, but prices should be regulated to ensure hospitals are not unfairly maximizing profits
@92GNRT33yrs3Y
Hospitals deserve all the money they can get
@927K9GT3yrs3Y
Hospitals should be non profit and funded based on population.
@8ZSH8WQ3yrs3Y
No, public hospitals should be funded to cover the needs of the population with simple day surgery cases, investigations and straightforward elective surgery’s outsourced to the private sector in the way government departments outsource straight forward projects to the private sector in the same way legal briefs are outsourced
@8ZRC4LY3yrs3Y
Something needs to be changed to help stop the ambulance ramping and delay problems
@8ZNNBKF3yrs3Y
no, all healthcare should be free and provided for by higher taxes
@8ZNMKB63yrs3Y
Only if it’s for non emergencies such as purposely self inflicted injuries. Otherwise, things such life threatening illnesses should be serviced without a fee.
The Medicare standard needs to raise substantially. Specialists charge based on the AMA model and above that. The system is broken
@LenascallyGreen3yrs3Y
Depends on service being provided
This should be unregulated.
No - hospitals should be government funded to offer free services
@8VC6KG4Independent3yrs3Y
No, but allow only for costly services and treatments
@8VC6KG4Independent3yrs3Y
No, but only for costly services and treatments
The current system with options for Medicare and private healthcare is sufficing.
@8TCKQJGIndependent4yrs4Y
Yes, and only necessary services allowed.
@Anderson94yrs4Y
Yes, this helps keep costs at a standardised rate nationwide, but work towards a better system
@8RP42RF4yrs4Y
Yes, and only necessary services allowed
@8QWKK2J4yrs4Y
Yes, but all options have to be presented and explained to patients. measures should be taken to avoid hospitals prescribing more expensive treatments
@8QCW34P4yrs4Y
Yes, but measures should be taken to avoid hospitals prescribing more expensive treatments
@8LM6G9C4yrs4Y
Yes, but all options have to be presented and explained to patients.
@8D2H6GM4yrs4Y
Free healthcare like Canada
No idea what this means.
Yes, but regulate the services they provide and fees that are paid for each service
@92LTWLD3yrs3Y
I am confused by this question.
Health care should be paid for by the government.
No, Healthcare should be free
@962KL2Y2yrs2Y
Yes, but guidelines with appropriate redressal should be in place to prevent misuse
No, and hospitals should not charge for any service. Being healthy is a benefit of society, not a privilege of wealth.
Yes, but only for some surgery
@96KQRRP2yrs2Y
Treat those that are important not useless unintelligent human beings
Yes but put more barriers in so they don’t do unnecessary treatment for profit
@92ZPL5B3yrs3Y
Yes but regulate the services they provide and fees that are paid for each service
@92ZDPT63yrs3Y
medical care should be provided free of charge to those who unable to pay
No, but there needs to be measures to ensure some standardised rates
@993JBF82yrs2Y
There are procedures where there will not be an accurately reflected fee for the condition being treated. Rare diseases, novel therapies, etc. But general procedures like a tonsillectomy, colonoscopy, removal of a carcinoma, have more definitive cost outcomes.
@8G64H7Z4yrs4Y
Yes because although it may encourage unnecessary expensicve treatments, more importantly it doesn’t discourage necessary expensive treatments
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.