In October 2015, Education Minister Simon Birmingham revealed a proposal that would cut funding to universities and deregulate the fees that they charge students. The Parliamentary Budget Office estimated that tuition fees would increase by 40% if universities were allowed to set them without government regulation. Proponents, including Mr. Birmingham, argue that the cost of university funding has grown at twice the rate of the economy since 2009. Opponents argue that the PBO’s estimate of 40% is too low and tuition fees will easily double or triple if the government ceases to regulate them.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Political party:
Federal Electorate:
Local Government Area:
Postcode:
@4TDPJSCLiberal Democrat4yrs4Y
Capable students should be on scholarships. Everyone else should find another path in life.
@4T4F9RK4yrs4Y
Yes, I am sick of people in Australia having this entitlement that they expect the government to aid them.
@4T764V5Liberal Democrat4yrs4Y
Maintain University funding for Australian born citizens but allow the universities to set fees for international students.
Yes but the reduction should be on their inflated bureaucratic level.
@4T94L6M4yrs4Y
ALL schools, colleges, universities should run by Christian churches, industry associations & be free in exchange for national service.
top 10% of students get free education. The rest can pay what the universities deem fair.
No, university education should be free for all citizens but they should either work in the field to pay back the debt or pay back HECS without indexation. Nothing is free, the taxpayer paid for your education you pay it back.
@B4PDVJD1wk1W
No, but universities should be more subsidised for industries that need an influx of students/workers.
Universities should have some control to set their own fees however, government funding should remain
@B4KZYZR2wks2W
Yes, for private establishments and end their funding. Public universities should provide free education to all citizens
@B4FRLNC3wks3W
they should set own fees and have room for assistance to those who couldn't afford to attend if they want to enrol
@B4FJRGV3wks3W
Universities should set their own fees but should be regulated, audited and capped in some way to prevent universities from overcharging students.
The fees shouldn't be so high to begin with to the point it becomes a detriment to your future that it cancels out the point of you doing it for your future. There should be set prices and government funding, otherwise if there's no government funding then the prices will go up onto the individuals to subsidize the university and affect what facilities can be utilized by the students.
@B3VMCWX1mo1MO
Yes, should allow for government assistance for scholarships. Universities can charge fees at the value they believe they provide to students for future success
@B3RF2P52mos2MO
I believe degrees should be priced based on societal importance. Nursing, Healthcare , Education, Sciences should be free as there is a universal need for employment in these positions. Degrees in subjects such as the Arts should come with a price as they provide less use for society as a whole. Im studying an arts degree in the aims of persuing an education degree but it is unrealistic to view philosophy with the same importance as healthcare professions. Also trades should be encouraged more often.
@B3QNFS82mos2MO
No, I would subsidise costs associated with practicals and placements and make some university payments subsidised on completion of a degree.
@B3PGPZR2mos2MO
Yes but fees for much needed occupations should be subsidized fully by government and reviewed annually, ie nurses, certain trades, etc
@B3NJRP42mos2MO
Degrees should be shortened the the bare essential units. Additional units may be optional. A degree should cost no more than $20,000.
@B3MBJCF 2mos2MO
No, and there should be more free courses but not all courses should be free as that would be a burden on the tax payer
@B3JP49D2mos2MO
I think free is unrealistic and unreasonable. But I think the price should equivocate what is appropriate for students who are typically entering early adulthood/financial independence and have minimal funds.
I think they should reduce costs students have to incur for universities but unis should still set costs in order to create competition for better facilities, encouraging better education hopefully in the process
@B2YFY7J2mos2MO
no, make it more affordable for domestic students and make it harder to get in so that people will be allocated to jobs that don’t need degrees
No, they should have government funding and hecs debt shouldn’t fluctuate with inflation.
@9DLJYWD2yrs2Y
Yes, but interest rates for student should be abolished.
@9DF9MJTOne Nation2yrs2Y
Not if they receive government money.
@9DDBFK52yrs2Y
Yes but they need to be overseen more in terms of setting parameters for students that affect their fees and structures that affect student wellbeing
Yes, but with Government influence.
@99PFY3B2yrs2Y
Universities should be extraordinarily cheap. Like 10 grand and not something over 100,000
@B3Y6XZM1mo1MO
Yes, however, they should cap it at a certain point, and have guidelines of how to price their tuition fees.
@B3KMC272mos2MO
Yes, medical professions should have their hex debit written off after they have worked in the Australian public sector for a fixed period of time (to be determined).
@B39CPKJ2mos2MO
No, but the fees should be reasonable, and partial government funding on some, specifically in areas where there are shortages in order to encourage students into that field perhaps
@B38V6JJ2mos2MO
Should be a maximum of AUD4000 a year for Australian citizens and international students should pay the current fees set by the universities
@B389CH72mos2MO
Every citizen of Australia should be given a fund of for example $30,000, they should do with it as many higher education courses (uni or tafe) as they want when they have run out of funds that is it they have to pay out of pocket then. There should also be a mandated amount of seats of every university course for Australian citizens. Fees should be regulated for Australian Citizens and unregulated for foreigners.
@B388WPZ2mos2MO
It should be controlled for citizens but not for non-citizens, Every citizen should be given $x amount for higher education (uni or tafe) but once the founds are out its out.
@B3628292mos2MO
If they are private universities they should be able to set their own fees. Public or government funded institutions should not be able to.
@B358G682mos2MO
No, If the Universities are allowed to set their own fees, then they can charge more money to university students.
@B33ZG2T2mos2MO
No, and university education should be free for all citizens while non citizens pay more to compensate the tax difference.
@B333L682mos2MO
I think that University scholarships should increase as there are so many gifted people out there who cant afford tuition costs/ who are put into a lot of Uni debt.
@B2ZKPNL2mos2MO
Make uni free but very hard, in order to increase worker employability and to allow those who shouldn't be there (because they're dumb) to root themselves out.
@B2WX9MK2mos2MO
Yes, taking into account the quality of education as well as the cost of the education for the university
Private owned universities should be allowed to set their own fees. Government owned ones shouldn't.
Yes for certain categories of students (short vocational courses that are corporate sponsored) Should be free for all citizens under 30yo but restrict foreign students to 10%. Raise standards if entry and eliminate soft marking.
End education incentive for PR visa and reduce international student s to 10%. Fund citizen student under graduate 100% but have higher academic entry standards and depoliticise courses
@9ZSXL7F5mos5MO
Universities should set their own fees, with adequate and reasonable financial aid being provided to select students. However, government funding for these universities should be ended.
@9ZL34PSIndependent5mos5MO
No, and univerisity education should be free for all citizens only for useful degrees like STEM degrees and only for the first degree a person undertakes and only if they complete that degree.
No, and university fees should be free for those who show they are serious about their academics and can't afford it.
University fees have to be highly regulated and checked every fiscal year by the State and Federal Governments to avoid fleecing both Citizens and Migrant students.
@9X98BLM6mos6MO
Universities should set their own fees but with a commitment to providing accessible education and not making profit.
@9WV5Y6Z6mos6MO
This seems like a state or federal election question. It's complex and would create a major debate. There should maybe be regulations though.
@9WNFST36mos6MO
Should be capped fees enforced by governments, where universities provide insight into how fees are paid for and why the prices are set at their respective fees for courses.
@9WCGJDG6mos6MO
Universities should add their own fees but not expensive that people cannot attend straight out of secondary school.
@9VYX78R6mos6MO
Yes but they should be reduced and made more accessible for students with pricing and payment plans and there should also be a postgraduate plan that is made for each individual student to help/guide them to achieve their goal career goals for after they graduate.
there should be government regulation on university fees that still allows universities some decision in fee setting.
@9V9V2VL7mos7MO
They should be acceptable for students not too high, but enough so university's can afford good teachers.
Personally, universities should not have fees to just go to the campus but fees for accommodation and the use of the library.
University education or most education should be funded by the government. Even if you study something, you can still struggle with finding employment. The amount of money you have to pay for a course is insane given the low chances you have of getting a job after studying a chosen field. Given the easy access of learning in general on the internet, school/course study should be funded by the government. It may be impossible, so at least universities and TAFE courses, or tickets for other skillsets should be government funded.
@9T6W4G68mos8MO
Yes, but with government regulation to prevent overpriced fees which will spiral students into decades of hecs debt.
@9SVJ8CX8mos8MO
Only to a certain amount, and I think they should give more opportunities for scholarships and discounts and do more to SUPPORT students. This includes more opportunities for chaplaincy, curriculum review, and pathway, as well as course length and financial aid that doesn't put people into ridiculous amounts of debt.
@9RZRC7P9mos9MO
Universities should discuss with the government so that both the university and the government are still being properly funded, but with a reduction on the amount of student debt nation wide.
@9RSXS5H9mos9MO
No, and governments should help reduce education costs to allow higher skilled workers to enter the force
We should offer a system similar to our schooling system. Public universities are free. Minus books etc. private university system similar to our normal school system
Yes and government should fund degrees where skills shortage are present conditional on recipients working in area
No university should be free but it should be limited, as it would be taking the piss if someone goes to study for 20 years and never goes into the work force to fund it for other people
Yes, and universities should be funded by government and university-employing industries (tax) alone
@9K8TZN2New Liberal1yr1Y
No, however I would like to see a considered reform of education from Pre-School to University in an integrated fashion with a dual focus on generating liberally educated democratic citizens whom can help to inform and set themselves toward areas of national need, having regard or open ended 10 and 20 year directions and visions for the Nation.
Governments should fully fund university education in order to promote educational power, resulting in increased active citizenship and thus increased civic engagement with citizens' right to democracy
If they aren`t able to pay for the fees at the current time, the government should pay some % of the fees and when the students start earning they payback. Similar to a loan
@9J54WTY1yr1Y
No, and start subsidising Australian university fees for in demand fields for Australian and New Zealand citizens.
Goverment ran univerisity should be free, while independent should be able to set fee's independently
@9HJXLNQ1yr1Y
I believe university education should be free for all citizens. If the student fails, they will still have to retake the course/degree, etc. Everybody should have access to education - it's a right.
@9GM9DDV1yr1Y
Universities fees should be adjusted like Medicare rebates, and to a certain point be covered by the government. The rest should be paid out of pocket by the student.
@9GJ673V1yr1Y
Current system of subsidised education by the government works well. Unis should set their own fees however should continue to be subsidised.
@9GGMN381yr1Y
If they are private institutions they can set their own prices. If government funded, then the fees should be regulated.
No, the government should set a definite fee on someone based on what type of education they are seeking and how "much" education they look for
Depends on the uni course and where the uni is as well as if the person is an Australian citzen or not.
Yes, but the fee should be lowered so houses with a single minimum wage income can pay for university.
@9FNH2K72yrs2Y
If they wish then they can
@9FFQK5S2yrs2Y
fees should be reduced, government should still help fund universities but make university education more accessible financially.
@9FDSDSD2yrs2Y
they should make the eduaction of certain jobs higher price.
@9FCTQHN2yrs2Y
No, university education should be free for all citizens who have citizenship included immigrants that have green card or international students that currently studying in australia
@9FB8KYY2yrs2Y
There should be both options
@9F53VMX2yrs2Y
Yes, but there should be a maximum, it should be regulated, and it should be proportional to how much it costs the university instead of overinflated fees.
@9F3DRKV2yrs2Y
Depends on if the university is public or privately owned/.
@9F2TPZ82yrs2Y
No, but for ones that aren't government affiliated can.
@9F2CSRK2yrs2Y
Universities should be able to set their own fees, however the government should strongly regulate how universities set their fees such as determining a reasonable maximum and minimum.
@9DWYZP62yrs2Y
No, but for some extra activities that need a small fund then, small fees might be reasonable.
@9VDY9ML7mos7MO
depends, if they increase the fee for the university, i said no, but if it decrease the fees i would agree due to helping the people who have less money
No, and university education should be free for all citizens and government funding for universities
@9BRZVDJ2yrs2Y
Yes but it has to be free for international student studying and has to be some maximum fee the university can set and has to be regulated by government.
@9BPGRZH2yrs2Y
tax should increase and uni decrease, if not become free
@9BJ8YFY2yrs2Y
No, university education should be lowered in price but students should still have to apply and successfully be accepted into the system.No, the government should regulate university fees, and supply support for low income earners
@99Z6WPS2yrs2Y
Yes, but create an upper limit based on factors such as the economy around the area, universities' reputation and statistics, etc
@99Z5QLT2yrs2Y
Should be free for important needed roles such as nursing and teaching
Government should find provided there is an outcome review regularly
@99YF5VK2yrs2Y
Yes, but within a reasonable range set by government
@96KVZR53yrs3Y
Yes, but based on the government funding they receive, which I believe should be increased
@96FSSJY3yrs3Y
yes, but they should be small fee the government should still partially pay for alot of it
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.