In 2015 the U.S. House of Representatives introduced the Establishing Mandatory Minimums for Illegal Reentry Act of 2015 (Kate’s Law.) The law was introduced after San Francisco 32 year old San Francisco resident Kathryn Steinle was shot and killed by Juan Francisco Lopez-Sanchez on July 1, 2015. Lopez-Sanchez was an illegal immigrant from Mexico who had been deported on five separate occasions since 1991 and been charged with seven felony convictions. Since 1991 Lopez-Sanchez had been charged with seven felony convictions and deported five times by the U.S. Immigration and Naturaliza…
Read more@8WSHQ8M3yrs3Y
No, but they should be served a sentence within this country.
@9LLRF341wk1W
Depends what the crime is. If they can do their time here then do it here but if its really bad send them back
@9L9H59R3wks3W
no, they should be treated as if they are an equal, the same law should be unforced as they use on everyone else
They should go to jail for their sentence and then be released back into Australia and not deported.
No, providing they have lived in Australia for a period of 7 years or longer, or they have gained citizenship. If this is inapplicable, then they can be eligible for deportation.
It depends on the crime, if it's putting a large amount of people in danger to have them in the country then yes, but if its serious but wont be putting people in possible danger to have them around just have them treated as any other Australian citizen and place them in prison or other legal actions.
@9K2CGYK2mos2MO
No, only if the crime is serious like murder or rape. If it is something like drug trafficking, rehabilitation programs should take place to help redeem themselves.
@9JYX3M92mos2MO
They can be deported if there countyr is safe, if not they can be sent to prison, as long as there proven guilty or have enough proof.
If they serve time for their specific crime and is trustable to be let out and live in our country and wants to stay, they have every right to as long as they obey the Australian laws.
In certain instances it seems appropriate, as an example if someone were to commit a terrorist act it's reasonable to deport them. However, if they commit manslaughter or attempt at murder they shouldn't be deported.
@9HXB3RZ4mos4MO
I believe if they become a citizen of Australia and adopt our rules they should be treated as Australian. So they will be treated as any other. However, if they have not received citizenship and have fommited a serious crime they should be deported. It also opens up the question as to what is classified as a serious crime.
@9329DPP2yrs2Y
Yes, if they are a repeat offender and commit a crime following their prison sentence
@93292NT2yrs2Y
Yes, but only for violent or terrorism offences
@92ZK8V62yrs2Y
If they are not citizens, that's fair
@92ZH9C32yrs2Y
Each case should be assessed individually taking real consideration of the individual circumstances
@92YF8LY2yrs2Y
If the crime is terrorism/against Australia, then yes. If it any other serious crime they should be sentenced like any other Australian
@92YDMPT2yrs2Y
They should be dealt with the same as citizens.
@92Y548R2yrs2Y
What counts as an immigrant? Unless one is indigenous, we are all immigrants
@92XVRH92yrs2Y
If they have lived in Australia for more than 5 years than No but if they have lived in Australia for less than 5 years they should be deported if safe to do so.
@92XTM8W2yrs2Y
No, but they should follow the Australian law for committing that crime
Depends on their visa status and the type of crime committed
@92XSMVG2yrs2Y
Depends if they are Aussie without a passport - iow been here since 1 or 2 years old and then they ARE Aussie.
@92XSKBH2yrs2Y
Yes, though we should not deport criminals that could face lesser or no conviction in their county of origin.
@92XCX322yrs2Y
Yes, if the crime is a felony, violent, financial, or sexual crime
@92WJQSC2yrs2Y
I believe they should serve their prison sentence the same as any other Australian.
@92WHVNM2yrs2Y
Yes, but only if it is within the first 5 years living in Australia, otherwise they serve their sentence in Australia
I think immigrants should be treated the same as any other citizen.
@92WGCY92yrs2Y
No let them serve their time and stay
@92WGB852yrs2Y
They should be given time in gaol like all other Australians
@92WFXFJ2yrs2Y
they should go to the same amount of respect as others
@92WFX6G2yrs2Y
Yes and no depending on the crime and how many people it effected
@92WFX4S2yrs2Y
yes and no, it depends on what kind of crime it is, how bad it is and how many people it effected. if they can get back to their country safely, yes.
@92WBP9Q2yrs2Y
Yes and No. Determine this on a case by case basis by examining whether the person is consistent with the countries values or not.
@92TS33M2yrs2Y
if its terrorism or murder yes. Anything else just put them in prison.
Yes, if their country is unsafe relocate elsewhere
@92TJRK62yrs2Y
Not if they grew up here, makes no sense if Australia taught them the cunningly way to send them to a country where they know no one
@92SZGWDIndependent2yrs2Y
Yes, once crime is committed send them on their way, tax payers money is worth more spent else where than on housing them in jail
@92SZ4QP2yrs2Y
Yes if they do so during a probation period prior to becoming a citizen
@92SXKLB2yrs2Y
Only murder nothing less
@92SW9SG2yrs2Y
No, they should be sentenced the same as an Australian.
@92STHT32yrs2Y
No, they should finish serving their sentence
@92ST2GN2yrs2Y
No, they should be treated the same as a citizen who commits a crime
@92SSLNPOne Nation2yrs2Y
Yes. But only if they enter our country illegally. Australian taxpayers shouldn’t have to keep them in our prisons
@92SRJCK2yrs2Y
Citizens no Residents and visa holders yes
@92SGF9D2yrs2Y
No, not if they are now an Australian Citizen, or if they were born and raised in Australia.
Depending on definition of "serious crime" and danger to society
@92S3XJN2yrs2Y
They should be able to choose if they want to serve time here or at home
Yes, but only if they arrived when they were adults and if it is safe to return to their own country
I’m a law abiding kiwi and terrified of this law
The historical activity of users engaging with this question.
Loading data...
Loading chart...
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...